"Madden"
Nicolas Cage plays football legend John Madden (see insert) in “Madden,” from Amazon MGM Studios

"Madden"

Nicolas Cage as John Madden and Christian Bale as Al Davis team up for one of the worst sports biopics ever.

By Peter Travers

Share this post

0 ★ (0 out of 4)

It gives me no pleasure to report that Oscar-nominated director David O. Russell, following his spectacular flameout with “Amsterdam,” screws the pooch badly in “Madden.” This early Thanksgiving turkey, available in theaters and Prime Video, is a gridiron biopic featuring fatuous fat suit acting from Nicolas Cage as football legend John Madden, the legendary head coach for the Oakland Raiders, longtime NFL telecast commentator and the namesake of the Madden NFL video game series.

Christian Bale also loses all contact with subtlety and shading as Al Davis, the Raiders’ owner and general manager who loved the big guy through thick and thicker until his death at 85 in 2021. Both actors start at over the top and speed into the stratosphere of hamboning from which audiences are offered no protection or money-back guarantees.

Hall of Shame stuff, right here

Look, my review of “Madden” is going to be short. A forensic analysis would only make the bad seem worse. I’m sure Russell, who also wrote this thing, and the actors, most experienced enough to know their crimes of too-muchness would not go unpunished, are sorry for inflicting their damaged goods on an unwary public. If not, they should be. In May 2025, several actors and crew members on the set of the film allegedly walked off after Russell used the n-word and also tried to insert it into the film's dialogue, then "belittled" other cast and crew members over objections to his use of the word. Sheesh.

Here’s a brief sense on what’s on the autopsy table. There’s a lot of strained camaraderie between Madden and Davis, culminating with a victory in Super Bowl XI. Away from football, the film follows Madden’s marriage to Virginia Madden (Kathryn Hahn). Carol Davis (Sienna Miller) is Al’s wife, Vince McGary (Shane Gillis) is Madden’s next-door neighbor, and Mike (Simms May) and Joe (Luke Klein) are John and Virginia’s sons. John Mulaney, bless him, shows up as Trip Hawkins, who persuades the coach to take on a side hustle in video games. The games are pretty good. The movie is not.

Oscar winners Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale overkill it in “Madden,” from Amazon MGM Studios

The film ends—it’s not really a spoiler—with both men being inducted separately into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. We also hear the real Madden’s 2006 induction speech, in which he credits Davis with giving him his chance as head coach and says he’s convinced their bronze busts talk to one another after hours. Let’s hope it won’t be about this movie. Hall of Shame stuff, right here.

Start with The Weekly Take — Free Newsletter

Get Peter’s latest reviews and commentary delivered to your inbox. Upgrade anytime to step Inside the Screening Room for his members-only perspective.

SUBSCRIBE

Share this post
Comments